TonyT wrote:My take is this: (big picture)
You can choose to like Silvers, hate him, take him at face value, or mistrust him. What he has achieved with his website has furthered the understanding of suppressors, and has caused all manufacturers to step up their game, now that they are being directly compared to one another. It has brought a cottage, word-of-mouth industry into the limelight, and has in many ways legitimised it, and furthered the advancement of design by (almost) all manufacturers.
I choose to like him (don't know him personally, only met briefly), and take him at face value.
Excellent post. I agree with you 100%.
When Robert started his independent testing, he didn't know Kevin or anyone from AAC. He had no relationship with the company. Kevin was (as far as I know) the only silencer manufacturer who encouraged the independent testing Robert was performing. While some other companies tried to discredit test results, AAC provided off the shelf products for Robert to test. Other companies wouldn't give Robert the time of day.
Like him or not, Robert helped educate a LOT of people. His tests forced many manufacturers to make product improvements and raise the bar. This has been good for all of us.
For the record, I had a customer the other day wanting to buy several AAC cans. The guy later contacted me and decided to drop one of the AAC cans and go with one from another company BASED ON ROBERT'S RECOMMENDATION! Robert calls things as he sees them.
That is my opinion at least.
Mark