Can for FN Five-Seven
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 6:27 pm
New owner of FN Five-Seven and intend to have the barrel extended and threaded by Tornado technologies. Trying to decide on a suppressor and looking for input. What would you recommend?
MY SYNOPSIS: The Gemtech SFN57 may be the best performer, with the best dimensions and no need for a thread adaptor, but you can’t dissemble it. Possibly the next quietest model of those with published tests is the Tactical Solutions Axiom, and it is also lighter than the Sparrow or the Spectre II. Leaning towards the Axiom, but I’m open to suggestions, including other brands and models if there is sound test data.
INTENDED USE: Home defense on first floor of our house to preserve hearing and reduce muzzle flash. Short and light suppressors may help with maneuverability around corners. Also will target shoot to build experience and have fun, possibly on a M&P 22lr as well as the Five Seven.
Thanks and hope the rest of this long post is helpful to others looking for similar summaries of available data
-------------------
TESTED SUPPRESSORS & DIMENSIONS
So far this is the data I’ve turned up. These are suppressors in production with sound tests published I could find. All have about a 1” diameter, except for the Gemtech which is 1.25"
Silencerco Spectre II 6” long 6 oz ($295 at Silencershop)
Tactical Solutions Axiom 5.95” long 6 oz ($304 at Silencershop)
Silencerco Sparrow 5” long 6.5 oz ($380 at Silencershop)
Gemtech SFN57 5.8” long 5.2 oz ($511 at Impact Guns) – Sealed can
POLLS
A poll in an FN forum which does not include the Axiom (too new?).
Sparrow 15 votes
SFN57 8
Spectre II 4
http://fnforum.net/forums/fn-five-seven ... -help.html
SOUND TESTS
* Differences in testing and/or ammo appear to make major differences in measured results. For example, the Sparrow is tested by two different sources below with different outcomes. The first five-shot average reductions are 30.88 db with SS197 vs 24.52 db with unspecified ammo.
Silencerco
SS197 (10 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 161.96 db
SS Sparrow - Dry
First Shot 132.55 (29.41 db reduction)
Best (Shot 6) 130.51 (32.24 db reduction)
Average (10 shots) 130.67 (31.36 db reduction)
SS Sparrow – Wet
First Shot 124.72 (37.24 db reduction)
Best (Shot 2) 123.57 (38.39 db reduction)
Average (Shots 1-6) 125.54 (36.42 db reduction)
Average (10) 127.67 (34.29 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffzm8kDKLQM
Silencershop
Std Velocity? (5 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 160.8 db
Silencerco SS Sparrow - Dry
First Shot 137.8 (23.2 db reduction)
Best (shot 2) 133.7 (26.6 db reduction)
Average (5 shots) 136.24 (24.52 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nc3_QolyetM
Silencerco Spectre II - Dry
First Shot 130.2 (30.8 db reduction)
Best (shot 1) 130.2 (30.8 db reduction)
Average (5) 132.08 (28.68 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZK5LvbPvCk
Tactical Solutions Axiom - Dry
First Shot 135.3 (25.7 db reduction)
Best (Shot 5) 129.8 db (31 db reduction)
Average (5) 131.72 (29.04 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2_p3HrwZR4
-----------
NFA Talk also has test results but the only one of the above models is the Gemtech.
SS195 ammo (11 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 163.6 db
First Shot 136.2 db (27.4 db reduction)
Best (shot 2, 4) 129.0 (34.6 db reduction)
Average (11-First) 130.44 db (33.16 db reduction)
Average (11) 130.96 db (32.64 db reduction)
http://nfatalk.org/forum/showthread.php?t=716
http://nfatalk.org/forum/showthread.php?t=745
MY SYNOPSIS: The Gemtech SFN57 may be the best performer, with the best dimensions and no need for a thread adaptor, but you can’t dissemble it. Possibly the next quietest model of those with published tests is the Tactical Solutions Axiom, and it is also lighter than the Sparrow or the Spectre II. Leaning towards the Axiom, but I’m open to suggestions, including other brands and models if there is sound test data.
INTENDED USE: Home defense on first floor of our house to preserve hearing and reduce muzzle flash. Short and light suppressors may help with maneuverability around corners. Also will target shoot to build experience and have fun, possibly on a M&P 22lr as well as the Five Seven.
Thanks and hope the rest of this long post is helpful to others looking for similar summaries of available data
-------------------
TESTED SUPPRESSORS & DIMENSIONS
So far this is the data I’ve turned up. These are suppressors in production with sound tests published I could find. All have about a 1” diameter, except for the Gemtech which is 1.25"
Silencerco Spectre II 6” long 6 oz ($295 at Silencershop)
Tactical Solutions Axiom 5.95” long 6 oz ($304 at Silencershop)
Silencerco Sparrow 5” long 6.5 oz ($380 at Silencershop)
Gemtech SFN57 5.8” long 5.2 oz ($511 at Impact Guns) – Sealed can
POLLS
A poll in an FN forum which does not include the Axiom (too new?).
Sparrow 15 votes
SFN57 8
Spectre II 4
http://fnforum.net/forums/fn-five-seven ... -help.html
SOUND TESTS
* Differences in testing and/or ammo appear to make major differences in measured results. For example, the Sparrow is tested by two different sources below with different outcomes. The first five-shot average reductions are 30.88 db with SS197 vs 24.52 db with unspecified ammo.
Silencerco
SS197 (10 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 161.96 db
SS Sparrow - Dry
First Shot 132.55 (29.41 db reduction)
Best (Shot 6) 130.51 (32.24 db reduction)
Average (10 shots) 130.67 (31.36 db reduction)
SS Sparrow – Wet
First Shot 124.72 (37.24 db reduction)
Best (Shot 2) 123.57 (38.39 db reduction)
Average (Shots 1-6) 125.54 (36.42 db reduction)
Average (10) 127.67 (34.29 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffzm8kDKLQM
Silencershop
Std Velocity? (5 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 160.8 db
Silencerco SS Sparrow - Dry
First Shot 137.8 (23.2 db reduction)
Best (shot 2) 133.7 (26.6 db reduction)
Average (5 shots) 136.24 (24.52 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nc3_QolyetM
Silencerco Spectre II - Dry
First Shot 130.2 (30.8 db reduction)
Best (shot 1) 130.2 (30.8 db reduction)
Average (5) 132.08 (28.68 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZK5LvbPvCk
Tactical Solutions Axiom - Dry
First Shot 135.3 (25.7 db reduction)
Best (Shot 5) 129.8 db (31 db reduction)
Average (5) 131.72 (29.04 db reduction)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2_p3HrwZR4
-----------
NFA Talk also has test results but the only one of the above models is the Gemtech.
SS195 ammo (11 shots)
Unsuppressed Average 163.6 db
First Shot 136.2 db (27.4 db reduction)
Best (shot 2, 4) 129.0 (34.6 db reduction)
Average (11-First) 130.44 db (33.16 db reduction)
Average (11) 130.96 db (32.64 db reduction)
http://nfatalk.org/forum/showthread.php?t=716
http://nfatalk.org/forum/showthread.php?t=745