Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
-
- New Member
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 3:37 pm
Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
When the law says the dealer (or transferor) has to pay it.
Last edited by rankhornjp on Fri Oct 17, 2014 12:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Bendersquint
- Industry Professional
- Posts: 11357
- Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 7:19 pm
- Location: North Carolina
- Contact:
Re: Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
Please cite your reference to the requirement of the dealer having to pay your transfer tax.rankhornjp wrote:When the law says the dealer has to pay it.
Re: Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
The short answer is so that the dealer doesn't charge you an extra $200. Also, it's transferor, not dealer...even though most of the time the transferor will likely be a dealer.
What you're probably referencing is 26 USC 5811 (b) By whom paid:
The tax imposed by subsection (a) of this section shall be paid by the transferor.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5811
The long answer is it's a matter of convenience. It doesn't say the dealer can't charge you and extra $200 for paying it for you, but it's likely more convenient for you to just cut the check. When a form 4 could be submitted via eForm it was probably paid by the dealer, after you paid the dealer the $200 to begin with. If the dealer gives you the paperwork to send in, you're likely sending the check directly. If the dealer says they will pay the tax for you, they already included it in the price of whatever they sold you, and any haggling you do to get them to pay the tax was already included in the markup.
What you're probably referencing is 26 USC 5811 (b) By whom paid:
The tax imposed by subsection (a) of this section shall be paid by the transferor.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5811
The long answer is it's a matter of convenience. It doesn't say the dealer can't charge you and extra $200 for paying it for you, but it's likely more convenient for you to just cut the check. When a form 4 could be submitted via eForm it was probably paid by the dealer, after you paid the dealer the $200 to begin with. If the dealer gives you the paperwork to send in, you're likely sending the check directly. If the dealer says they will pay the tax for you, they already included it in the price of whatever they sold you, and any haggling you do to get them to pay the tax was already included in the markup.
-
- New Member
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
That is the correct section that I'm referencing. The question came from reading several discussions on whether or not a trust needs it's own bank account and I found that section while researching it for myself. So, in this case, it seems that the BATFE doesn't care who writes the check, as long as they get paid....telero wrote:The short answer is so that the dealer doesn't charge you an extra $200. Also, it's transferor, not dealer...even though most of the time the transferor will likely be a dealer.
What you're probably referencing is 26 USC 5811 (b) By whom paid:
The tax imposed by subsection (a) of this section shall be paid by the transferor.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/5811
The long answer is it's a matter of convenience. It doesn't say the dealer can't charge you and extra $200 for paying it for you, but it's likely more convenient for you to just cut the check. When a form 4 could be submitted via eForm it was probably paid by the dealer, after you paid the dealer the $200 to begin with. If the dealer gives you the paperwork to send in, you're likely sending the check directly. If the dealer says they will pay the tax for you, they already included it in the price of whatever they sold you, and any haggling you do to get them to pay the tax was already included in the markup.
- Bendersquint
- Industry Professional
- Posts: 11357
- Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 7:19 pm
- Location: North Carolina
- Contact:
Re: Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
As long as it is paid ANYONE can pay for it, neighbors, friends from Germany, anyone.
Re: Why do we pay the $200 tax on Form 4s?
Correct. ATF doesn't care who the $200 comes from. But the way the regs are written, the transferror is the party who is responsible for it being paid.Bendersquint wrote:As long as it is paid ANYONE can pay for it, neighbors, friends from Germany, anyone.
Of course, it's all academic at this point. Because if no one pays the tax, the forms aren't going through.
I suppose someone could sue their dealer after paying for a MG or silencer and have the court compel the dealer to pay the tax... and the buyer would end up wasting a lot more time and money in the process.